Happy Thanksgiving week, y’all! While Christmas is my favorite holiday when it comes to all the pomp and circumstance that goes along with it, Thanksgiving reigns supreme in the food department. All the menu planning and table setting gets me so excited that the holidays have arrived and really just brings me so much joy. What are y’all eating this year? I’m keeping it simple this go around, sticking to the classics (i.e. mashed potatoes, green bean casserole, cranberry sauce) while leaving room to experiment with some more fun recipes come Christmas dinner. Honestly I’m just here for the mashed potatoes. I could dive into a cloud of potatoes and be the happiest person around – I mean, what’s not to love about buttery and fluffy potatoes? Since I’m in charge of all the cooking, that also means I’m tasting and nibbling at things all day long. My brother has caught me multiple times over the years eating spoonfuls of the mash during the day before dinner. I just love them so much!!!
A couple people have asked me how I handle the holidays and times of indulgence since I stick to a pretty healthy regimen the rest of the year. Honestly, I am such a huge #treatyoself proponent and that’s the mindset I use when it comes to holiday treats. I mean obviously don’t eat a thousand Christmas cookies and then wonder why you feel like garbage, but eat a cookie here and there, add those marshmallows to your holiday party cocoa, serve yourself a little bigger piece of pie if you want it. I really do think life is all about the balance, and one day of indulgent eating for the holiday isn’t going to ruin your life, especially if you don’t eat those things on a regular basis. Just get back on track after and understand what your body needs to feel its best. I hate feeling like I can’t have something, so when someone offers me a little holiday treat I take it, being mindful of when my body actually wants and needs something and when I need to cool it and serve up a kale salad.
So speaking of balance, this is where this pie comes in. It’s a Coconut Cardamom Cream Pie with a Pecan and Coconut Crust. OMG. I’m not usually one for lightening up foods for the holidays, those recipes never turn out quite as good, but I figured I give it a shot when it comes to dessert. I feel like dessert is easier to lighten up and retain the taste and flavor than the main course. Agree or disagree???
Since I have the biggest sweet tooth in all the land, I wanted to see if it was possible to create a holiday pie that was slightly healthier so I could indulge more. LOL. And this guy was a winner on all fronts. There are a few places where you might notice the healthy swap outs, namely the crust, but it’s still a delicious and not too sweet dessert that satisfies that itch for sweetness. I love all things coconut, and there’s basically coconut in all layers going on here. The base is actually rendered with cashews, similar to a cashew cheesecake, but it’s creamier and lighter thanks to the coconunt milk that keeps it from getting too solid like some of those vegan cheesecake recipes I’ve tried. And that cardamom?? Don’t even get me started. It’s one of my favorite spices that has one of those subtle sweet and floral flavor to it and it’s just so perfect for this time of year. You could use cardamom powder here, but I think having the little broken pieces of fresh cardamom seeds make this pie so much more delicious. As for the crust, I kept it simple with shredded coconut and pecans pulsed in a food processor with a little coconut oil. You could try your hand at a graham cracker crust or a date-based crust if you are a fan of those little fruits (I am NOT – so I didn’t use dates here). This is also an ALMOST vegan pie if you left off the whipped cream, so at least your vegan friends could have a yummy pie at the holiday too. If you either left out the whipped cream (which would be sad) or subbed in coconut whipped cream – which I heard Trader Joe’s carries now?? – then you’ve got yourself a vegan coconut cream pie. You can tell it’s healthier than the original, but in a good way.
Now what are you doing? Go gather the ingredients and get to baking (I mean refrigerating? Because this is a no-bake pie!). Happy Thanksgiving!!
coconut cardamom cream pie
time – overnight + 30 minutes prep yield – 1 pie
for the crust –
2 cups of pecan halves
1 cup unsweetened shredded coconut
2 tablespoons of coconut oil
for the filling –
2 cups of cashews, soaked overnight/at least 8 hours
1 18oz can of coconut water (I used this brand)
2 tablespoons of granulated sugar
separated cream from two cans of coconut milk**
seeds from about 4 – 5 cardamom pods (about a teaspoon or so)
1 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
pinch of salt
- measure 2 cups of cashews into a large bowl and cover with water. set aside and let sit overnight, at least 8 hours.
- add the coconut water and sugar into a stovetop pot and bring up to a simmer over medium-high heat. reduce the coconut water to about half the amount until it’s slightly syrupy, about 15 – 20 minutes, stirring occasionally. (it won’t be as syrupy as a simple syrup)
- while the syrup is cooking, prep the crust. In a food processor, add the pecans and coconut flakes. Pulse until they start to come together. Add the coconut oil and continue to pulse until the mix is crumble-y in texture. The mix should come together and hold slightly when pressed in your hands. Add additional coconut oil if necessary.
- in a 10″ pie dish, press the crust mix into an even layer on the bottom and up the sides. Place in the fridge to set for about 15 minutes while preparing the filling.
- rinse the cashews and add to a high power blender with the coconut water syrup, coconut milk cream**, cardamom seeds, vanilla, and salt. blend on high until smooth, tasting and adjusting cardamom and vanilla flavor as desired.
- grab the pie crust from the fridge and pour the filling in. Spread the top out evenly and place in the fridge to set overnight until it holds its shape.
- to serve, top with whipped cream (homemade or store bought) and toasted coconut flakes. Enjoy!
**Ashlae from Oh Lady Cakes has a whole post on how to get this coconut cream from a can. Check out the post on how to get that perfect separation so you can use delicious coconut cream in your recipes.